TB Skin Test vs. Blood Test in The Diagnosis Phase
Tuberculosis (TB) is a grave infectious disease that affects millions of people worldwide. It is caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis, a bacterium that primarily affects the lungs but can also impact other parts of the body.
Diagnosing TB can be challenging, and there are various methods available for detection. Two commonly used tests are the TB skin test and the TB blood test. Although both tests aim to identify the presence of TB bacteria in the body, they differ in methodology and accuracy.
In this article, we will compare the TB skin test and the TB blood test to help you understand which one is more accurate in detecting TB. So, if you seek information on TB diagnosis, continue reading to learn more on how to differentiate the TB skin test vs. blood test.
Understanding TB skin test vs. TB blood test
Detecting TB can be a complex task, and several methods are available for its identification. Two widely employed tests are the TB skin test and the TB blood test. Although both tests aim to detect TB bacteria in the body, they employ different approaches and exhibit varying levels of accuracy.
The TB skin test vs. blood test comparison is important for understanding their differences. The TB skin test, also known as the Mantoux test, is a simple and cost-effective procedure. It involves injecting a small amount of purified protein derivative (PPD), a substance, beneath the skin on the forearm. After 48 to 72 hours, a healthcare professional examines the injection site for the presence of a raised bump or swelling. The size of the bump is measured and interpreted to determine whether the person has been infected with TB bacteria.
On the other hand, the TB blood test, also referred to as the interferon-gamma release assay (IGRA), is a newer and more expensive method. It entails taking a blood sample and analyzing it in a laboratory to identify specific proteins produced by the body in response to TB bacteria.
Understanding the differences between the TB skin test vs. blood test is crucial in determining which test is more suitable for accurate TB detection. The choice between these two tests depends on various factors, including cost, availability, and the individual’s specific circumstances. Consulting a healthcare professional can provide further guidance in selecting the most appropriate test for TB diagnosis.
How TB skin test works
The TB skin test functions by detecting the immune response in the body against TB bacteria. When TB bacteria enter the body, the immune system generates T cells, a type of white blood cells, to combat the bacteria and produce a protein known as interferon-gamma. The TB skin test measures the amount of interferon-gamma produced by the T cells in response to the PPD injection.
If an individual has been infected with TB bacteria, their immune system will have generated T cells that target the TB bacteria specifically. When the PPD is injected under their skin, the T cells recognize the TB proteins in the PPD, prompting the production of interferon-gamma. This, in turn, leads to a raised bump or swelling at the injection site.
When comparing the TB skin test vs. blood test, it is important to note that the TB blood test works differently. It detects TB infection by analyzing the presence of specific proteins in the blood that are released in response to TB bacteria. Instead of measuring the immune response at the injection site, the TB blood test directly examines the blood sample for these proteins.
How TB blood test works
The TB blood test detects the presence of particular proteins called interferon-gamma release assays (IGRAs) that are produced by the body in response to TB bacteria. A blood sample is collected and analyzed in a laboratory to identify these proteins, which are generated by T cells upon exposure to TB bacteria.
Compared to the TB skin test, the TB blood test is more specific. It exclusively detects the presence of TB bacteria and avoids false positive results caused by other bacterial types. Moreover, the TB blood test is less likely to yield false negative results in individuals who have received TB vaccination or have previously been infected with TB bacteria.
Accuracy of TB skin test
The accuracy of the TB skin test relies on several factors, including the type of test employed, the size of the PPD injection, and result interpretation. In general, the TB skin test is less accurate than the TB blood test, as it may yield false positive results in individuals who have received TB vaccination or have previously been infected with TB bacteria.
According to a study, the TB skin test exhibits a sensitivity of approximately 70% to 85% and a specificity of around 98% to 99%. This means that the TB skin test can correctly identify 70% to 90% of individuals infected with TB bacteria and can accurately identify 98% to 99% of individuals who are not infected with TB bacteria.
Accuracy of TB blood test
The TB blood test is more accurate than the TB skin test since it can specifically detect the presence of TB bacteria with fewer false positives. According to research, the TB blood test has a sensitivity of approximately 96.4% sensitivity and 94.1% specificity.
This indicates that the TB blood test can correctly identify 93% to 95% of individuals infected with TB bacteria and can accurately identify 97% to 98% of individuals who are not infected with TB bacteria.
Advantages and disadvantages of TB skin test and TB blood test
Both the TB skin test and the TB blood test have their own advantages and disadvantages. The TB skin test is more affordable and easier to administer compared to the TB blood test, and it can be conducted in a doctor’s office or clinic. However, the TB skin test is less accurate than the TB blood test and may produce false positive results in individuals who have received TB vaccination or have previously been infected with TB bacteria.
On the other hand, the TB blood test is more accurate than the TB skin test and can be used in individuals who have received TB vaccination or have previously been infected with TB bacteria. However, the TB blood test is more expensive and requires a laboratory to process the blood sample.
When considering the TB skin test vs. blood test, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of each test based on factors such as cost, accessibility, and accuracy.
Who should get tested for TB?
According to the CDC, individuals at high risk of developing TB should undergo TB testing. This includes individuals who have had close contact with someone who has TB, individuals with HIV or other conditions that weaken the immune system, individuals who have recently arrived from countries where TB is common, and individuals who work or live in settings where TB transmission is more likely, such as healthcare facilities, prisons, or homeless shelters.
Which test is better for whom?
The choice of which test to use depends on various factors, including the individual’s age, medical history, and risk factors for TB. In general, the TB blood test is more accurate than the TB skin test and can be utilized in individuals who have received TB vaccination or have previously been infected with TB bacteria. However, it is important to consider that the TB blood test is more costly and requires laboratory processing of the blood sample.
When comparing The TB skin test vs. blood test, it is crucial to consider that the first one is cheaper and easier to administer compared to the TB blood test, but it is less accurate and may yield false positive results in individuals who have received TB vaccination or have previously been infected with TB bacteria. In certain cases, both tests may be used together to confirm a TB diagnosis.
Choosing the Right TB Test: Considerations for Accuracy, Cost, and Convenience
The TB blood test is more accurate than the TB skin test, but it is also more expensive and requires laboratory processing of the blood sample. The choice of which test to use depends on factors such as individual risk factors for TB and medical history. If you are at a high risk of developing TB, consult your healthcare provider to determine which test is most suitable for you.
Unlocking Advanced Healthcare Solutions: Simplirad’s Commitment to Healthcare in India
Simplirad is a leading health company dedicated to PACS, RIS, and hospital information systems, committed to promoting health in India. We understand the importance of accurate TB diagnosis, which is why we offer advanced solutions to Hospitals and Clinics.
Visit the Simplirad homepage today to learn more about Telemedicine and Teleradiology.
